California’s top court overturns Scott Peterson’s death sentence

    0
    17

    The California Supreme Court on Monday unanimously overturned the death penalty for Scott Peterson, who was convicted of killing his wife, Laci, and their unborn son in 2002.

    In a decision written by Justice Leondra Kruger, the state’s highest court said the death sentence must be removed because the trial judge wrongly discharged prospective jurors who expressed opposition to capital punishment but said they would be willing to impose it.

    The court left in place the guilty verdict and said prosecutors could retry Peterson on the penalty if they wished.

    “Before the trial began, the trial court made a series of clear and significant errors in jury selection that, under long-standing United States Supreme Court precedent, undermined Peterson’s right to an impartial jury at the penalty phase,” Kruger wrote.

    The court said the rules for dismissing potential jurors based on concerns about the death penalty were well established by Peterson’s trial.

    “Jurors may not be excused merely for opposition to the death penalty, but only for views rendering them unable to fairly consider imposing that penalty in accordance with their oath,” Kruger wrote.

    Instead of just dismissing the prospective jurors, the judge should have permitted them to be questioned so their views could have better been explored, the court said.

    “As the present case demonstrates, an inadequate or incomplete examination of potential jurors can have disastrous consequences as to the validity of a judgment,” Kruger wrote.

    The Scott Peterson Murder Trial

    The Scott Peterson Murder Trial

    In addition to challenging the removal of prospective jurors, Peterson had argued that massive pretrial publicity deprived him of a fair trial.

    Peterson’s trial was moved to San Mateo County after a judge found he could not get a fair trial in Modesto. Peterson’s appellate lawyer argued the trial should have been moved again after questionnaires of more than 1,000 potential jurors in San Mateo County showed many already were convinced Peterson was guilty.

    But the court said the publicity was so widespread that moving the trial to yet another county would not have mattered.

    “Precisely because this case was the subject of such widespread media attention, it is unclear what purpose a second change of venue would have served,” the court said. “The publicity the Peterson trial generated, like the trials of O.J. Simpson, the Manson family, and any number of other so-called trials of the century before them, was intrinsic to the case, not the place.”

    Prosecutors in Stanislaus County must decide whether to try once again to seek the death penalty or agree to commute the sentence to life without possibility of parole.

    John Goold, a spokesman for the Stanislaus County district attorney’s office, said prosecutors were still examining the ruling Monday and had not yet decided how to proceed.

    “We are going to have to review the decision and get together with the victim’s family before any decision is going to be made,” Goold said.

    Cliff Gardner, Peterson’s appellate lawyer, appeared doubtful Monday that prosecutors would seek a new trial on the penalty. He said the California Supreme Court was now reviewing a separate habeas corpus challenge filed on behalf of Peterson that contained “new forensic and eyewitness evidence of innocence.”

    “In deciding whether to seek a new death sentence, the question for prosecutors now is whether they can prove Mr. Peterson culpable for this crime to even a single juror seated through a fair jury selection process,” Gardner said.

    Peterson is confined at San Quentin prison, where scores of inmates have been infected by the coronavirus and several have died. Asked if Peterson had contracted the virus, Gardner said only: “He is doing fine now.”

    Laci Peterson, 27, was due to give birth in four weeks when she disappeared on Christmas Eve. Scott Peterson told police he had left their Modesto home that morning to go fishing in Berkeley.

    Nearly four months later, Laci’s remains and the body of her unborn son, with the umbilical cord still attached, washed up on a rocky shore on San Francisco Bay. A passerby walking a dog found them a few miles from where Scott Peterson said he had gone fishing.

    Laci’s disappearance sparked a massive search. At first her family did not suspect Scott. That changed after a massage therapist named Amber Frey told police that she and Peterson had been dating, and that he had told her his wife had died. She then secretly recorded calls with him for the police.

    Police arrested Peterson in San Diego County. He had bleached his hair and goatee and was carrying $15,000 in cash.

    Prosecutors told jurors that Scott either strangled or suffocated his wife on the night of Dec. 23, 2002, or the following morning. He wrapped her body in a blue tarp, put her in the back of his boat, affixed anchors to her and dropped her in the bay, they said.

    Mark Geragos, who defended Peterson at trial, argued Laci had been kidnapped by strangers who dumped her in the bay to frame her husband.

    You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.

    Maura Dolan is the California-based legal affairs writer for the Los Angeles Times. She covers the California Supreme Court and the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals. A California native, she graduated from UC Berkeley and has worked in Washington and Los Angeles for The Times. She is now based in San Francisco.

    California

    ‘Like Armageddon’: Rotting food, dead animals and chaos at postal facilities amid cutbacks

    California

    ‘Like Armageddon’: Rotting food, dead animals and chaos at postal facilities amid cutbacks

    Accounts from employees at California postal facilities provide a glimpse of the chaos amid both the pandemic and widespread cuts imposed by the USPS.

    California

    The fight to save one Northern California town from a fiery monster

    California

    The fight to save one Northern California town from a fiery monster

    The fire, dubbed the CZU Lightning Complex fire, had burned 63,000 acres, destroyed 97 structures and forced the evacuation of about 77,000 people in San Mateo and Santa Cruz counties.

    Sports

    Plaschke: I had COVID-19, and these are the things nobody tells you

    Sports

    Plaschke: I had COVID-19, and these are the things nobody tells you

    L.A. Times sports columnist Bill Plaschke talks about experiencing COVID-19. Yes, he says, it’s really as bad as you’ve heard.

    Lakers

    Plaschke: Lakers’ LeBron James goes into attack mode, becoming Playoff LeBron in Game 3 win

    Lakers

    Plaschke: Lakers’ LeBron James goes into attack mode, becoming Playoff LeBron in Game 3 win

    In his third playoff game with the Lakers, LeBron James finally showed a city draped in purple and gold exactly what the fuss was all about.

    World & Nation

    Public officials move to muzzle violent outbursts by anti-maskers

    World & Nation

    Public officials move to muzzle violent outbursts by anti-maskers

    Masks. Leading public health authorities all but beg people to wear them during the coronavirus crisis.

    California

    Reopening elementary schools is risky — but so is keeping them closed

    California

    Reopening elementary schools is risky — but so is keeping them closed

    Experts say it’s going to be a tough call for figuring out how to get elementary schools reopened. Reopening elementary schools when disease transmission is too high is risky.

    Opinion

    Op-Ed: Pandemics spread like wildfire, and fire is a contagion too

    Opinion

    Op-Ed: Pandemics spread like wildfire, and fire is a contagion too

    Sports

    Plaschke: I had COVID-19, and these are the things nobody tells you

    Sports

    Plaschke: I had COVID-19, and these are the things nobody tells you

    L.A. Times sports columnist Bill Plaschke talks about experiencing COVID-19. Yes, he says, it’s really as bad as you’ve heard.

    California

    Back to school in a pandemic: Resources and news for parents

    California

    Back to school in a pandemic: Resources and news for parents

    The new school year of remote learning will bring unique challenges. Here are guides to help parents of school-age children navigate remote learning, as well as recent updates about education in Southern California.

    California

    8 Pomeranian puppies smuggled from Russia intercepted at LAX

    California

    8 Pomeranian puppies smuggled from Russia intercepted at LAX

    Inspectors at Los Angeles International Airport intercepted eight Pomeranian puppies that were smuggled into the U.S. from Russia, authorities said Monday.

    California

    Fans celebrate Kobe Bryant Day in Orange County with favorite memorabilia and memories

    California

    Fans celebrate Kobe Bryant Day in Orange County with favorite memorabilia and memories

    Like many, Alexander Kolosow and his son, Alex II, celebrated Kobe Bryant Day in Orange County with their favorite collections and memories of the late Lakers star.

    California

    O.C. man masquerading for years as federal agent pulled over motorists, obtained guns, feds allege

    California

    O.C. man masquerading for years as federal agent pulled over motorists, obtained guns, feds allege

    For years, investigators say, Donovan Nguyen has masqueraded as a federal agent, carrying firearms, pulling over motorists and purchasing guns with fake law enforcement credentials.

    California

    Ban on flavored tobacco sales is approved by California Assembly

    California

    Ban on flavored tobacco sales is approved by California Assembly

    The California Assembly on Monday approved a ban on the retail sale of flavored tobacco products in the state, with supporters saying it is needed to reduce smoking and vaping by minors and others attracted by fruit and menthol flavors.

    California

    Abandoned by authorities, these fire-threatened towns set up their own FEMA-like response

    California

    Abandoned by authorities, these fire-threatened towns set up their own FEMA-like response

    They couldn’t get help from the state. Or the feds. So volunteer firefighters in two Santa Cruz mountain towns tapped an elite network of emergency responders.

    Sign up for the latest news, best stories and what they mean for you, plus answers to your questions.

    You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.



    SOURCE: https://www.w24news.com

    Donnez votre point de vue et aboonez-vous!

    Laisser un commentaire

    Votre point de vue compte, donnez votre avis

    [maxbutton id= »1″]




    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here